• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Make With Mara logo

  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • TikTok
Home » Savory » Halloween Pasta Salad

Halloween Pasta Salad

Published: Aug 26, 2022 by Mara · This post may contain affiliate links - as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This Halloween Pasta Salad is spooky and delicious! We use a combination of everyday and speciality ingredients and equipment to make this side dish delicious and festive for any Halloween party. Your guests and ghouls will be coming back for more! BONE-appetit!

A black bowl of halloween pasta salad on a white background surrounded by mini orange pumpkins, candles, and bottles. In the pasta salad are mini pumpkin shaped pasta, mini basil leaves, sliced cherry tomatoes and skull shaped mozzarella.

Everyone loves pasta salad! This Halloween Pasta Salad is ghoulishly delicious and is perfect to serve at this year's Halloween party. I've made a few tweaks to my Tortellini Caprese Salad to make this fa-BOO-lous! We're using festive pumpkin shaped pasta, skull shaped mozzarella and a parmesan balsamic vinaigrette. Then, you can add in any additional vegetables of your choice to fully customize this pasta salad to your liking.

If you're looking for more Halloween treats and sweets for your next party or scary movie night check out my Halloween Caprese Skewers and Ghost Rice Krispie Treats.

Why You'll Love this Recipe

  • Easily customizable
  • A festive twist on classic pasta salad
  • Can be made ahead
  • Perfect for halloween parties and gathering
A close up angled photo of Halloween Pasta Salad in a black bowl with pumpkin shaped pasta, mini basil leaves, sliced cherry tomatoes and mozzarella skulls sitting on a white marble table. In the background are assorted decorations of mini orange pumpkins, clear glass bottles and candles with a dark red background.

Ingredients

Halloween Pasta Salad ingredients on a white marble table. Each ingredient is labeled with a dark red box with white text in all caps.
  • Pasta - I used a local Colorado brand I found at Whole Food's. They are zucca shaped pasta which are mini pumpkin shaped which made sense for this fall holiday. However, you can use whatever your favorite medium shaped pasta is.
  • Tomatoes - I grabbed a variety of cherry tomatoes. I love the color they bring to this side dish.
  • Mozzarella - For this recipe, I used fresh mozzarella balls (not in water). These can be found in the specialty cheese section of your grocery store. For my sized mold I used the ciliegine sized (cherry size, ⅓ ounce) mozzarella balls.
  • Basil - I used fresh sweet basil for this recipe. I love the pop of color.

Parmesan Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • Olive Oil - use fresh and high quality extra virgin olive oil for richness and body.
  • Balsamic Vinegar - for bold flavor and sharp acidity, use a high-quality balsamic vinegar from Italy. White balsamic vinaigrette is a great variation made with sweeter and milder white balsamic vinegar instead.
  • Dijon Mustard - used as an emulsifier/ binds our dressing ingredients together.
  • Parmesan - I used grated parmesan for a subtle cheesy flavor that compliments the pasta salad.
  • Garlic - I prefer fresh, but you can substitute with garlic powder.
  • Salt, Pepper + Chili Flakes - to balance the acidity and add a kick of spice.

Step-by-Step Instructions For Creating Mozzarella Skulls

A white plate with a black rim with paper towel and mozzarella balls on top. A dark red circle is in the upper left corner and a '1' in white text color.
  1. Pre-heat oven to 350°F. While oven is preheating, put several sheets of paper towel on a large plate. Then, spread out the mozzarella balls and place several more sheets of paper towel on top of the mozzarella. Finally, place a large book or cast iron skillet on top, to act as a weight and let it sit for 5-10 minutes.
A white square ceramic baking dish with 8 pieces of mozzarella balls on a black wire trivet on a black background. A dark red circle is in the upper left corner and a '2' in white text color.
  1. Once oven is pre-heated, take a small ceramic baking pan and add in 8 pieces of mozzarella to the pan. Bake in the oven for about 6-7 minutes.
A white square ceramic baking dish with 8 pieces of slightly softened mozzarella balls on a black wire trivet on a black background. A dark red circle is in the upper left corner and a '3' in white text color.
  1. Remove pan when the cheese if softened and some of the liquid is released/slightly melted but not completely melted or cooked! Place pan on a cooling rack.
Two skull silicone molds and a mozzarella ball in each crevice. A back of a gold spoon presses mozzarella in the mold crevice. A dark red circle is in the upper left corner and a '4' in white text color.
  1. Using a spoon(s) or mini tongs, carefully pick up one piece of mozzarella at a time and add it to the mold. Then, using the back of one spoon press down on the mozzarella for 20-30 seconds until it molds more to skull. Repeat with remaining mozzarella. If the mozzarella isn't taking to the mold. Put back mozzarella back into the pan and place back into the oven for a few more minutes and try again. Once all the mozzarella is pressed in the molds, place the molds in the fridge for 10 minutes.
8 mozzarella shaped skulls in a white low bowl on a black wire trivet on a black background. A dark red circle is in the upper left corner and a '5' in white text color.
  1. Pop mozzarella skulls out of the mold and into a bowl or airtight container if storing for later. Keep in the fridge. Rinse and dry our molds and pan and repeat steps 2-5 until you have used all your mozzarella. (I had to do this a total of 3 times = 24 mozzarella skulls total)

Step-by-Step Instructions for Making Pasta Salad

Pumpkin shaped pasta in a colander with water rinsed on top of the pasta. In the upper left corner is a white '1' in a dark red circle.
  1. Cook pasta al-dente according to package directions. Once cooked al dente, drain in a colander and rinse with cold water to cool pasta.
A jar of dressing on a white marble table. A white '2' is in a dark red circle in the upper left corner.
  1. In a jar, add in all dressing ingredients and twist on lid. Shake for 30 seconds - 1 minute until dressing is combined and emulsified.
A small white bowl of sliced cherry tomatoes on a a small tan cutting board with a large chef knife in the background. It sits on a black table. A white '3' in a dark red circle in the upper left corner.
  1. Wash and slice tomatoes, as well as wash and chop or pull basil if serving right away.
A black bowl of halloween pasta salad on a white background surrounded by mini orange pumpkins, candles, and bottles. In the pasta salad are mini pumpkin shaped pasta, mini basil leaves, sliced cherry tomatoes and skull shaped mozzarella. A white '4' in a dark red circle is in the upper left corner.
  1. Toss cooled pasta salad with dressing, mozzarella skulls, tomatoes and let it sit in the fridge for 5 minutes for flavors to marinate. Toss again, add basil, taste and adjust seasoning as need. Serve and enjoy.

Expert Tips

  • Season the pasta water well - The water should be salty to impart flavor on the pasta plus it keeps pasta from sticking together.
  • Don’t overcook the pasta - Use the package directions of the pasta you choose as a guide and cook al dente. If done, drain the pasta and move onto our next tip.
  • Rinse the cooked pasta under cold water before tossing with the dressing. If you’ve ever made pasta salad that turned sticky, not rinsing the pasta before tossing with the dressing could be the reason. The cooked pasta is coated in starches. By removing the starches, the salad won’t turn sticky or clump as much. Rinsing the pasta will also keep the pasta from continuing to cook.
  • Check the seasoning!: The flavor of pasta salad changes when cold. Make sure to toss the pasta salad after refrigerating to evenly redistribute dressing. Taste and re-season as needed before serving.
Halloween Pasta Salad in a black bowl with pumpkin shaped pasta, mini basil leaves, sliced cherry tomatoes and mozzarella skulls sitting on a white marble table. In the background are assorted decorations of mini orange pumpkins, clear glass bottles, black salad serving utensils and candles with a dark red background.

Recipe FAQs

Why do you rinse pasta for a cold pasta salad?

Rinsing the hot pasta in cold water until it's cooled stops the cooking process. No one wants mushy overcooked pasta salad. It'll also remove any extra starches on the pasta.

Can I make this pasta salad ahead of time?

Yes, you can!  I actually recommend making it a full day ahead of serving so the ingredients have plenty of time to blend their flavors! I would just recommend only putting about ½ the dressing on and saving the other ½ of dressing and basil on right before serving.

Are these molds safe to put in the oven?

While these molds are primarily used for ice they can also be used for candy making, sugar, mousse and ice cream. I reached out to the seller/manufacturer and confirmed that these molds were safe to be in the oven at 180 degrees Celsius which equals roughly 356 degrees Fahrenheit. However, because some peoples ovens can run hot, etc. I decided it was better for me to add in a step of having the mozzarella softened in a baking pan then added to the mold.

What else can I add to this pasta salad?

What I love about how simple this pasta salad is how you really can add in a ton of different toppings and extras to make this pasta salad to your preference. Here's a list of some additional items you can add.
- Carrots, broccoli, spinach, olives, sun-dried tomatoes, marinated artichokes, cucumbers, red onion, bell pepper, avocado, corn, salami, arugula, chickpeas, grilled chicken.
The only thing I would note is to make more dressing if you are adding more ingredients in.

You Might Also Like

  • A mixing bowl full of Chicken Club Pasta Salad with chives on top on a white marble background
    Chicken Club Pasta Salad
  • Tortellini Caprese Salad in a speckled octagon bowl topped with fresh basil and balsamic glaze on a white marble background. A small white bowl of balsamic glaze and small wood bowl of sea salt sit in the background. A pair of gold utensils are crossed in the foreground with cherry tomatoes and a piece of basil.
    Tortellini Caprese Salad

PS If you try this recipe, why not leave a star rating in the recipe card right below and/or a review in the comments section further down the page? I always appreciate feedback. You can also follow me on Pinterest, Facebook or Instagram.

A black bowl of halloween pasta salad on a white background surrounded by mini orange pumpkins, candles, and bottles. In the pasta salad are mini pumpkin shaped pasta, mini basil leaves, sliced cherry tomatoes and skull shaped mozzarella.

Halloween Pasta Salad

Mara
This Halloween Pasta Salad is super festive to serve at your next Halloween party or gathering. Skull shaped mozzarella, colorful cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, your favorite pasta and a parmesan balsamic vinaigrette makes this a super tasty recipe.
4.50 from 2 votes
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 20 minutes mins
Cook Time 28 minutes mins
Resting/Cooling Time 38 minutes mins
Total Time 1 hour hr 26 minutes mins
Course Side Dish
Cuisine American, Italian
Servings 6 people
Calories 207 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 8 ounces medium pasta shell of your choice I used zucca or mini pumpkin shaped
  • 12 ounces cherry tomatoes
  • .5 ounces basil

Parmesan Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • ½ cup olive oil
  • ¼ cup balsamic vinegar
  • ¼ cup grated parmesan cheese
  • ½ teaspoon minced garlic
  • 1 teaspoon dijon mustard
  • chili flakes, salt + pepper to taste

Instructions
 

Mozzarella Shaped Skulls

  • Pre-heat oven to 350°F. While oven is preheating, put several sheets of paper towel on a large plate. Then, spread out the mozzarella balls and place several more sheets of paper towel on top of the mozzarella. Finally, place a large book or cast iron skillet on top, to act as a weight and let it sit for 5-10 minutes.
  • Once oven is pre-heated, take a small ceramic baking pan and add in 8 pieces of mozzarella to the pan. Bake in the oven for about 6-7 minutes.
  • Remove pan when the cheese if softened and some of the liquid is released/slightly melted but not completely melted or cooked! Place pan on a cooling rack.
  • Using a spoon(s) or mini tongs, carefully pick up one piece of mozzarella at a time and add it to the mold. Then, using the back of one spoon press down on the mozzarella for 20-30 seconds until it molds more to skull. Repeat with remaining mozzarella. If the mozzarella isn't taking to the mold. Put back mozzarella back into the pan and place back into the oven for a few more minutes and try again. Once all the mozzarella is pressed in the molds, place the molds in the fridge for 10 minutes.
  • Pop mozzarella skulls out of the mold and into a bowl or airtight container if storing for later. Keep in the fridge. Rinse and dry our molds and pan and repeat steps 2-5 until you have used all your mozzarella. (I had to do this a total of 3 times = 24 mozzarella skulls total)

Halloween Pasta Salad

  • Cook pasta al-dente according to package directions. Once cooked al dente, drain in a colander and rinse with cold water to cool pasta.
  • In a jar, add in all dressing ingredients and twist on lid. Shake for 30 seconds - 1 minute until dressing is combined and emulsified.
  • Wash and slice tomatoes, as well as wash and chop or pull basil if serving right away.
  • Toss cooled pasta salad with dressing, mozzarella skulls, tomatoes and let it sit in the fridge for 5 minutes for flavors to marinate. Toss again, add basil, taste and adjust seasoning as need. Serve and enjoy.

Notes

Season the pasta water well - The water should be salty to impart flavor on the pasta plus it keeps pasta from sticking together.
Don’t overcook the pasta - Use the package directions of the pasta you choose as a guide and cook al dente. If done, drain the pasta and move onto our next tip.
Rinse the cooked pasta under cold water before tossing with the dressing. If you’ve ever made pasta salad that turned sticky, not rinsing the pasta before tossing with the dressing could be the reason. The cooked pasta is coated in starches. By removing the starches, the salad won’t turn sticky or clump as much. Rinsing the pasta will also keep the pasta from continuing to cook.
Check the seasoning!: The flavor of pasta salad changes when cold. Make sure to toss the pasta salad after refrigerating to evenly redistribute dressing. Taste and re-season as needed before serving.
Are these molds safe to put in the oven? While these molds are primarily used for ice they can also be used for candy making, sugar, mousse and ice cream. I reached out to the seller/manufacturer and confirmed that these molds were safe to be in the oven at 180 degrees Celsius which equals roughly 356 degrees Fahrenheit. However, because some peoples ovens can run hot, etc. I decided it was better for me to add in a step of having the mozzarella softened in a baking pan then added to the mold.
 
Nutritional information for this recipe is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed. Please calculate your own nutritional information if you want it exact to what you make and use my calculations as a guide only.

Nutrition

Calories: 207kcal | Carbohydrates: 7g | Protein: 2g | Fat: 19g | Saturated Fat: 3g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 2g | Monounsaturated Fat: 13g | Cholesterol: 4mg | Sodium: 270mg | Potassium: 265mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 4g | Vitamin A: 602IU | Vitamin C: 16mg | Calcium: 57mg | Iron: 1mg
Tried this recipe?Tag me on Instagram @makewithmara or hashtag #makewithmara
« Halloween Caprese Skewers
Pumpkin Ricotta Pasta »

Reader Interactions

Did you make this recipe? Let me know! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Primary Sidebar

Hi, I’m Mara! The home baker and cook behind Make With Mara. This is where I share my love of recipe testing, plating, and all things tasty. Let’s crEATe something delicious together! More about me →

Popular Recipes

  • The Cookie
  • A slice of milano tiramisu on a small white plate. You can see cookie layer and vividly and cocoa powder is dusted on top.
    Hot Chocolate Milano Cookie "Tiramisu" with Bailey's Irish Cream
  • Whole Funfetti Chip Cookie Cake with a vanilla buttercream border and round colorful sprinkles. The cookie cake sits on a white and pink circle platter.
    Funfetti Chip Cookie Cake
  • A close up of a chocolate cupcake frosted with sea salt caramel chocolate frosting in a rosette. The cupcake is lined with a brown cupcake liner with another cupcake liner underneath but opened up. The cupcake sits on a white background with more cupcakes in the background
    Salted Caramel Chocolate Frosting

Fall Favorites

  • Overhead of Fall Cookie Cake with decorate buttercream pumpkins on a black wire trivet. The trivet sits on a cement background.
    Fall Cookie Cake
  • A vanilla cupcake with a white line with apple buttercream stacked tall on top. It has freeze dried apple bits decorating the cupcake. Behind it are more cupcakes and whole apples. Everything sits on a wood plank table.
    Apple Buttercream
  • Apricot Brie Bites on a grey platter with a white ring. The platter sits on a stone background. Each Apricot Brie Bite is made of a phyllo cup as the base, melted brie, an apricot topping and crushed pistachios.
    Apricot Brie Bites
  • Biscoff Cupcakes on a white marble table with a white background. Each cupcake has a white liner, topped with biscoff buttercream, a drizzle of biscoff spread and a biscoff cookie. There's cookie crumbs in front of the cupcake.
    Biscoff Cupcakes

Hi, I’m Mara! The home baker and cook behind Make With Mara. This is where I share my love of recipe testing, plating, and all things tasty. Let’s crEATe something delicious together! More about me →

Popular Recipes

  • The Cookie
  • A slice of milano tiramisu on a small white plate. You can see cookie layer and vividly and cocoa powder is dusted on top.
    Hot Chocolate Milano Cookie "Tiramisu" with Bailey's Irish Cream
  • Whole Funfetti Chip Cookie Cake with a vanilla buttercream border and round colorful sprinkles. The cookie cake sits on a white and pink circle platter.
    Funfetti Chip Cookie Cake
  • A close up of a chocolate cupcake frosted with sea salt caramel chocolate frosting in a rosette. The cupcake is lined with a brown cupcake liner with another cupcake liner underneath but opened up. The cupcake sits on a white background with more cupcakes in the background
    Salted Caramel Chocolate Frosting

Fall Favorites

  • Overhead of Fall Cookie Cake with decorate buttercream pumpkins on a black wire trivet. The trivet sits on a cement background.
    Fall Cookie Cake
  • A vanilla cupcake with a white line with apple buttercream stacked tall on top. It has freeze dried apple bits decorating the cupcake. Behind it are more cupcakes and whole apples. Everything sits on a wood plank table.
    Apple Buttercream
  • Apricot Brie Bites on a grey platter with a white ring. The platter sits on a stone background. Each Apricot Brie Bite is made of a phyllo cup as the base, melted brie, an apricot topping and crushed pistachios.
    Apricot Brie Bites
  • Biscoff Cupcakes on a white marble table with a white background. Each cupcake has a white liner, topped with biscoff buttercream, a drizzle of biscoff spread and a biscoff cookie. There's cookie crumbs in front of the cupcake.
    Biscoff Cupcakes

Footer

↑ back to top

Privacy Policy • Contact Me

Make With Mara 2022